Page 5 of 12

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:02 pm
by OneEye
Well first round is out of the way so we can get into this! So... any of you guys the bad guys or what? I won’t tell anyone I swearsies!

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:04 pm
by D_Arquebus
Sorry WTS,

Rabid and Foad and I were busy today with Online tourney on fumbbl.

It seems pretty plain that Foad would send himself no?

The downside, thanks to decisions made previously, is he hasnt been tested yet, for what that is worth.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:06 pm
by D_Arquebus
Which is a problem as I know Im a good guy. So one of those three at least will be a traitor and unlikely to let the mission succeed

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:23 pm
by whitetailscramblers
Ohh how did you go in the tournament? Sorry to derail.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:25 pm
by whitetailscramblers
Oneeye. Hmm only a bad guy would say that for sure. I have my eye on you.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:25 pm
by whitetailscramblers
Foad who are you thinking for the second party?

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:26 pm
by D_Arquebus
**Not done yet. 2/1/0 for me... 2/0/1 for Rabid... 2/0/0 for Foad as he is Bye Buster and TO :) . 2 more games tomorrow :) **

Now back to scheduled programing

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:55 pm
by Foad
WTS: Hutchie has the lay of it, shame on you for even suggesting that I put you OneEye, Olaf and you as the next team. That would totally say I'm OK with it failing, which would make me a terrible player as I'm clearly a good guy.

The trick is with 5-0 agreement on the party, everyone here has to assume that Merlin was OK with that party, which kinda vets Olaf and OneEye.

For us good guys to win, we have to get one of the 3 member missions over the line.

I can't agree to anything but a team of Olaf, OneEye and myself.

OneEye, Olaf and Foad to go on the next mission.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 8:04 pm
by whitetailscramblers
As the first party succeeded I am happy to support them being included into the mission. The question remains did a bad guy play possum in the first round or was it fortunate that two good guys were picked for the party.

Now without casting doubt on your Foad. Your claims of being a good guy have yet to be tested. Further too I would also be including myself into my choice of party as well. That way I know there is at least one good guy and attempt to identify the others.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 11:04 pm
by D_Arquebus
Thats a quick turn around Foad... :P

Re Merlin, by the same token you would have to assume that the 2 Bad Guys were ok with that party for some reason as well...

WTS - what you said in that first paragraph is directly "casting doubt on...Foad". You cannot do that and then tell him that is not what you are doing. You have set yourself directly against Foad by claiming the 3 you did should go. :P

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 11:11 pm
by D_Arquebus
What Im saying is that it seems clear that a Bad Guy may have played possum.

It seems unlikely the 2 Baddies would be ok with a pure Good Guy crew.. because it could lead to a 2-0 and then 3-0 result very easily if the 2nd team was 3 good guys too... Knowing I wasnt in the 2nd team and I am a good guy, it may make sense they knew it would fail because Foad is a Bad Guy and would be likely to go on the next mission? Dunno... OneEye tanked the possible read on that with his "its all random" shenanigans. :)

Olaf was laying some ground work to play silly buggers perhaps? Claims of OneEYe prepping him for a set up. But then he is making a claim to being busy and not able to post much. Perfectly legit re family and the current situation in the world outside Avalon :P ... but possibly also a ploy? Either way, may have changed the way he chose to play it.

WTS - making claims that the first 2 and he would be a winning team. Now Foad knows that is not true because HE is a good guy, or because he knows who the bad guys are. So either way his reasoning is unsound.

TL:DR - you could all be evil for all I know :P

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2020 11:25 pm
by D_Arquebus
The question becomes, do I let the mission fail, because Im not on it and its unlikely the Bad Guys would Double Bluff for a 0-2 and then 3-0 comeback...

Why would I? To learn something about what is done. Why Foad calling it so quick with little discussion is troubling...

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 2:06 am
by OneEye
Yeah Foad jumping straight into the team without much discussion is dodgy as hell BUT if he is a good guy and just wants to push it through quickly and Olaf is also a good guy and not a hiding bad guy, game over. We have our three good guys and the vote cannot be stopped by the baddies. Likelihood of that is very low but hey, not much else to go on!

Bring it on. I’ll be voting for the team to go ahead.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 2:09 am
by Rabid_Bogscum
Ok folks the group of oneeye, olaf and foad has been proposed. can everyone pm me whether you are happy with this group

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 4:14 am
by whitetailscramblers
I have allowed the group to progress to see what decision the bad guys make, but am a good guy. I also doubt that the bad guys will allow two successful parties in a row.

So what I cannot workout yet, is D. What he claims as a good guy and we have stacked the party with two bad guys. Or is D. Doing a convincing job of pretending to be a good guy. Time will tell.

I do not have enough knowledge of Foad to see if his very early call for the party was self assurance good guy or bad guy strategy.

What hasn't been considered (devil's advocate)is the first two picked were the bad guys and we have been on the back foot from the start.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 10:34 am
by Olaf_the_Stout
Completely out of game, my post on Friday night was not gamesmanship. I was feeling very average and was busy with other stuff. Fortunately I woke up yesterday feeling much better. I'm unlikely to post a lot as I'm still busy and more than a bit distracted, but am still sending through stuff to keep the game moving. Sorry, but that's the best I can offer at this point.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 11:18 am
by whitetailscramblers
Olaf. Good to see you can hang in with the game. Saves Rabid making changes or replacing your character......... was it good guy or bad guy again? 🤔

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 11:48 am
by Rabid_Bogscum
The group had decided. And Oneeye, Olaf and Foad headed off to grab some armour for their mission. D_Arquebus had a sour expression on his face.

Votes were 4 in favour of the group and 1 dissenting (D_Arquebus)


Can oneeye, olaf and foad pm me with whether they wish the mission to succeed

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 12:18 pm
by whitetailscramblers
Ohhhhh let's see what happens next.

Re: AWW #39 - Avalon - Mission 2

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 12:33 pm
by whitetailscramblers
D. By your last post you indicated that you would be supporting the nominated members. Why the last minute change?